Posterous theme by Cory Watilo

Filed under: newspapers

Why the Wall St. Journal Rocks

Media_httptomcuthbert_aqbbr
Recently, I've been griping about my local paper and newspapers in general.  The industry is in turmoil and changing rapidly.  One big change will be the way the paper will be read in the future.  Today's announcement about the Kindle DX will make it easier for people like me to eventually switch to a digital reader.  I like this idea and I cannot imagine how newspapers today, in their current form, will survive, except for one...  the Wall St. Journal. I have been an avid Journal reader for years.  The paper has changed for the better in recent years and is setting the pace for an industry in transition.  In fact, of all major newspapers in this country, the Wall St. Journal was the only one to INCREASE paid subscribers in the last month.  While an entire industry cuts content, moves online or folds all-together how can it be that the Journal grows?   There have been several recent changes that I believe have enhanced the reading experience, broadened appeal and made the paper more useful.  That list includes:
  • Media_httptomcuthbert_ferhl
    Added sports coverage
  • Adjusted the physical size of the paper
  • Enhanced the paid online version
  • Launched an iPhone app
  • Produce excellent podcasts and vidcasts
  • Broadened appeal with health, tech and travel
  • Reformatted the front page for easy scanning
But beyond these enhancements, fundamentally the I enjoy the Journal for three reasons.  First, the perspective is conservative yet thoughtful.  The OpEd page is engaging and thought provoking.  The editorial page in my local paper has become predictable and mundane.  Any column worth reading was syndicated from another paper.  There are essentially no independent thinkers or interesting writers.  While I don't always agree with Peggy Noonan, Kim Strassel or William McGurn, I do respect their perspective.  Secondly, the information I read in the Journal or hear on their podcasts is relevant to me.  Walt Mossberg and Katie Boehret are consistently exceptional with product reviews and insights.  The company coverage is great and news stories are engaging.  From travel to tech and health to book and wine reviews, it fits my lifestyle.
Media_httptomcuthbert_iflli
Finally the Journal entertains me in an intelligent way.  Each day there is a story on the front page that delves into topics ranging from Bollywood to windmills.  I'm a sucker for Pepper and Salt, the funny cartoon (my recent favorite at left).  The writing style is accurate when needed and relaxed when appropriate.  I also find the podcast with Gordon Deal to be a great compliment to the paper. So as newspaper executives across the country (and here in my hometown) are scratching their heads try to figure out why they are sinking, they should pick up a copy of the Journal.  I do... everyday. Tom Cuthbert

The Future of Newspapers

A few weeks ago I noticed that the Business section was missing form my Sunday paper.  I vented by posting a tweet and followed up by sending an email to the business editor of the paper.  After a few days I received a well written reply. It stated, 
Media_httptomcuthbert_ibuff
Unfortunately, we have discontinued the Sunday and Monday Business sections. We are not happy about it, but at the end of the day it was an action that had to be taken for the good of the institution. I am sure you are aware that we are on the cusp of technological, cultural and generational forces that are reshaping the information landscape. Add to that the most corrosive financial environment since the Great Depression and you can see the 
perfect storm that has slammed into the traditional business model for the general circulation newspaper.

First of all, I appreciate him taking time to respond.  I enjoy reading actual newspapers and read several of them every day.  I recognize that the industry is changing and in deep turmoil, but it seems to me there are lots of other areas to cut besides the Business section.  Maybe I'm not a typical reader since my favorite publication is the Wall St. Journal.      
My response was, in part...
Thank you for writing me back.  I recognize the difficulties all print publications have as people change habits to online.  I have followed the Seattle PI switch with interest and you are right, it is a changing world.  I know you guys are in a tough spot.  I certainly don't have the answers.  I can tell you as a technology person in this community I rely on your paper to keep me informed.  I will also tell you that  dropping Sunday and Monday will cause me to consider my subscription.    I encourage you to think of ways to enhance the coverage, more deeply engage readers, pull in more regional information and create new ways to rebuild, not retrench.  (Twitter and other social media outlets may hold some answers)

So what is the future for papers like mine?  Henry Blodget wrote and interesting article titled, "Our Plan to Fix the New York Times".  In it he discusses several options for papers.  
Media_httptomcuthbert_lijie
In the end, the business model is flawed given the access to data that people have.  Blogs, micro papers and online publications are pulling readership away from print.  Classified ads are less effective than ever now that they compete with Craigslist and EBay.  Even searching for homes has moved from print to Zillow and other online sites.

At the end of the day I do believe I predicted the future correctly when I wrote, 'Future conversation with my son (circa 2034) "Really Pop?  Someone actually 'threw' a PAPER copy of the news on our driveway?  No way!".  

Too bad, but that is the direction we are heading.

Tom Cuthbert